Open menu
Why is Public Education so Important?
Where is Plymouth on renewables?
A panel discussion
Watch on Youtube
LGBTQ+
Everyday Inclusivity
Considerations

Dr. Stephanie Sprout & Dr. Aimee Pascale
Donate
Support our work

Sununu Wants to Privatize Education

Rep. Joyce Weston
Plymouth

Most people who have grown up in New Hampshire have fond memories of going to school with the other kids in their town — the school bus rides, playground games, school lunch (yuck), team sports, and lifelong friendships.

On August 16, Chris Sununu diverted our taxpayer dollars — the money should be going to help our underfunded public schools reopen — to an unqualified, Koch-funded, for-profit company that is under investigation in Arizona. Under Sununu’s direction, the Department of Education will issue a no-bid contract from the pandemic relief bill portion for schools to this shady company, Prenda. The Governor is giving Prenda $6 million for its “learning pods”.

This money is from the bipartisan Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act, which contained $13.5 billion in “Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief” funds.

New Hampshire is now giving Prenda’s “micro-schools” more money per pupil than the state gives our local public schools. Its curriculum is taught by “guides” — not certified teachers, and there is little accountability.

These pods will be five to ten elementary or middle-school-aged students, taught by Prenda’s employees in school buildings or other public locations — Churches, perhaps? According to Prenda’s site, to become a “guide”, you must be at least 18 years old, pass a criminal check, be certified in CPR and first aid, have some facility with technology, and have six months of experience (paid or unpaid) working with children in the last five years.

Do you hear anything about academics? Learning styles? Classroom strategies? Lesson plans? Do the guides need to be educated beyond the eighth grade to teach? How will the students be evaluated for work in the larger world? Will they be prepared to enter college?

The money Sununu is giving to Prenda will create an additional 27 charter schools to add to the state’s current 29. Last I heard, prior to COVID, the existing charter schools were having trouble filling their seats. Some were closing down for lack of business. Do we really need to more than double the number of these schools?

Perhaps our local population prefers an accredited, accountable public school with a curriculum that adequately prepares them for adult life. Sununu appears to be trying to destroy the public school system.

[Printed in the Record Enterprise (September 1, 201) and other NH papers]

 

April 2021 Newsletter

Welcome
Welcome to our first edition of the Newsletter by the new Comms team. We are looking forward to making our newsletter as interactive and participatory as possible. Please add your voices so we can become more inclusive, diverse, and community owned.

The 2022 elections provide an opportunity for PAD to recruit new members and engage our current members in actions that will help us win decisive victories in Concord and Washington. Here are some ways you can support PAD :

  • Sign up to volunteer
  • Like, comment and share our Facebook, Twitter and Instagram posts

We want to partner with local progressive groups, labor unions, etc. to provide articles about their work and show what we Dems stand for. Do you know of groups around that we should contact ? If so please email me.


Chair’s Chair

Dear Neighbors, Friends and Secret Admirers,

Happy Spring 2021! I had my second Vaccine on April 27th and though I plan to continue to be safe, I am ready to start thinking about in person meetings this summer! We can meet outdoors, stay safe, and find once again an in – person community!

If you have not signed up to get vaccinated, please do. If you need help signing up, email me: mike@plymouthareademocrats.org

We have a lot going on. Please read this amazing Newsletter to learn all about it.

For this space I want to take a moment to welcome our new Executive Board Members, Gunnar Baldwin and Rita Sebastian. I also want to give a shout out to Bill Nesheim and Kimberly Rawson. Bill will be working with Gunnar on our Database and Technology broadly. Kimberly is working with Rita on Communications and Organizing. Both have already done a ton to help us get rolling.

I want to also make a request. If anyone has suggestions, concerns, praise, questions or if you just want to chat. Email me: mike@plymouthareademocrats.org. Please don’t expect an immediate reply. I have a job and a family. But know that I will reply. I will probably ask to set up a call, I like phone calls way more than emails. I love talking politics.

That is all for now. Please join us on the 4th Wednesday of the Month at 6pm for our Monthly Meeting every month February through October. You can sign up through Mobilize.

Before I leave you, please take a moment to set up a monthly donation to PAD. Every dollar donated will be used to grow PAD and elect local Democrats: https://secure.actblue.com/donate/plymouth-area-democrats-1

Love,
Mike
Mike Machanic
Chair – Plymouth Area Democrats


From the Executive Desk:

Our Executive Board has a lot going on. We welcome 2 new members while also gearing up for 2021. Lots happening.

In an effort to keep everyone informed; especially during COVID times when we can’t meet in person and have that nice hour before the meeting to eat and chat, we are going to start this section of the Newsletter where we share what it is the Executive Board is up to.

So, first update, Communications! As you may have seen we have doubled our efforts on Social Media. Please follow our Facebook Page AND join our Facebook Group., The Page is where we will post news, information (like Legislation to watch) and events. The Page is public and anyone can see it. The Group is for Democrats only. It is private. You will notice you cannot “share” information from the Group, but can from the Page. If you have something you want to share, for now, please post it to your own page and tell the group to go there to share. BUT soon we will have a place on our website for submitting information for the group.

This brings me to the next update, Technology. We love our Website. As many of you know Sarah Daniels Campbell revolutionized PAD’s Digital presence. We are hoping to take her foundation and grow from there. Gunnar will be adding functionality so that anyone in PAD can submit articles, events, or legislation information to the website easily. That information will be reviewed by the Executive Board and published on the Website and/or on Social Media (wherever appropriate).

Another area we are making changes is right here. The Newsletter. There will be a lot of changes to the Newsletter, but the most relevant is the cadence. Moving forward you should expect a Newsletter once a month, a week before our monthly meeting.

Monthly Meetings will continue to fall on the 4th Wednesday of the month, February through October, but they will begin at 6PM instead of 6:30 PM.
We are also launching a Speaker Series for Monthly Meetings and will be asking each Speaker to give us a reading list of books and/or articles that we will hopefully include in the Newsletter for the month BEFORE that speaker will be speaking.

Also on the Technology front, we are in the process of partnering with the NHDP to significantly bolster PAD’s data. We are hoping to make large improvements in our ability to reach likely Democrat Voters in all 18 PAD towns. The focus for 2021 will be finding those voters and trying to bring them into our community.

Lastly, BYLAWS! We have posted the Bylaws with the proposed amendments. The Board had a couple amendments and Representative Sallie Fellows had a few. They are all here: Please take some time to read them. We will have time to discuss at the meeting next week.

Please follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Changes to the Website will probably take some time, but we hope to have more to share next month.
Also, please take a moment right now to set up a monthly donation to PAD. Every dollar you donate will be used to grow our group and elect local Democrats:

Become a Monthly Donor


Vision / Mission Statement:

[The Vision Statement was passed at the Executive Board and will be voted on at the Monthly Meeting].

Plymouth Area Democrats (PAD) stands for economic, social and environmental justice where all people have the opportunity to vote, engage with their elected leaders and government institutions, and be appropriately represented. We remain committed to helping elect diverse and progressive policymakers, expanding opportunities for democratic action, and empowering grassroots participation in a manner that pays attention to—and shows respect for diversity — gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, race, geography, and socioeconomic status. Our goal is to build a world that reflects the diversity of its citizens, restores our democratic values, and once again follows the rule of law and justice. We work to manifest that goal and to bring about progressive social change through education, collaboration, mobilization, and empowering grassroots activism.

Introducing our speaker series

We will be introducing a speaker series at each of our monthly meetings. It will be an opportunity to educate our members by experts in the field, and support them by amplifying their voice. This is how we win! We stand with the People fighting to build a more ‘Just’ world.

April 28th: Moms Demand Action

Our first speaker is Elizabeth Allen from Moms Demand Action. New Hampshire’s gun laws are among the weakest in the country. Granite State law does not require background checks on all gun sales, or limit access to firearms by people in crisis. Come listen to our first speaker as part of our ongoing speaker series at our next monthly PAD meeting, April 28, 2021. Moms Demand Action is the largest gun violence prevention organization in the country with more than six million supporters. See how you can help change NH gun laws and keep our children safe!

May 26th: Legal Justice Policy Change, A New Paradigm

Our second speaker will be Thea Sebastian. Thea is a civil rights attorney and activist who is currently the Policy Director for Civil Rights Corps, a non-profit organization that has been spearheading impact litigation and policy advocacy nationwide to end criminal-legal injustice and build a new, non-carceral paradigm for public safety.
 
Thea will speak about why criminal-legal policy change is so essential, as well as some key projects like support for the Breathe Act (dubbed the “Civil Rights Act of the 21st century”) and the Vision for Justice campaign that she co-leads with the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights. Recommended Readings and Books follow.

 

RECOMMENDED READINGS
Reading recommendations from Thea Sebastian, Policy Director for Civil Rights Corps, “Legal Justice Policy Change, to end criminal-legal injustice and build a new, non-carceral paradigm for public safety”, Presentation, May 26th, 2021

Bail / Pretrial Justice

Criminalization of Poverty

MESSAGING WORKSHOP
Do you want to get involved in helping win the election for Dems?

Messaging is a critical tool to winning. George Lakoff’s book, “Don’t Think of an Elephant!”, talks about how conservatives frame their political messages more effectively than Democrats do. So let’s change that! We have a group on slack. Let us know if you are interested in joining it.
Recommended reading list:

Books by George Lakoff – The Political Mind and Don’t Think of An Elephant.

Workshop: Wednesday, April 21, 6:30 – 8pm EDT, reading group discussion of Lakoff’s books. Lakoff is A Cognitive Scientist who developed The Essential Guide to Thinking and Talking Democratic and framing the debate. (past time frame of newsletter coming out, but will post if there is a video).
 

Legislative Call to Action

HB 544, relative to the propagation of divisive concepts.
 
Over the past five years there has been no reduction in the racial disparity in fatal police shooting victims despite increased use of body cameras and closer media scrutiny Another Black man, Daunte Wright, 20 years old, was fatally shot during a traffic stop. This took place at the same time, 10 miles south, in Minneapolis, that the trial of former police officer Derek Chauvin, who faces murder charges in Floyd’s death is taking place. Given these incidents of police violence, now more than ever we cannot afford NOT to focus on the systemic issues underlying these and other tragedies. For this reason, we need your help to ensure that HB544- a bill that would prohibit schools, universities, and any businesses or other entities doing work for the State from teaching concepts that point to systemic racism—doesn’t become law.

HB 544 is tabled now. To help ensure that HB 544 doesn’t become law in our state, we must speak up. OPPOSE HB 544 in the budget. We’re asking you to take action today to help stop the language in HB 544 from progressing!

Diversity training belongs in NH. Contact your state senator today and urge them to remove the language from HB 544 from the budget.
 

Notes from the Campton conservation commission’s desk
Coming soon!

This column will feature regional conservation topics, projects, issues, or legislation of interest to voters.

Action Alert

From the Local Leadership Network
Join the Facebook Group

The Local Leadership Network’s Statewide Visibility actions are scheduled for Thursday, Friday or Saturday (April 22-24).

There are two main purposes to this action: (1) to hold Republicans in the Legislature accountable for their unacceptable behavior and proposals this session; and (2) to help you recruit members for your Committees.

The idea is:
You choose the day, time and place because no one knows your town like you The visibility can last from 30 to 90 minutes
Minimum # of sign holders required = 1
Progressives will drive by and wonder who you are. Some will join you next time and more the time after
Nothing is easier than holding signs – it’s fun and a great recruiting tool!

Here are some sample messages:

  • The NH Disadvantage = NH GOP Property Tax Hikes
  • The NH GOP Local Taxes = The NH Disadvantage
  • NH Republicans: Raising Your Property Taxes, Again!
  • Here We Go Again! NH Republicans = Higher Taxes
  • Believe your Tax Bill, Not Republican Lies!
  • NH GOP = Higher Property Taxes, Again!
  • Keep NH GOP Hands Off: Our Public Schools
  • Keep NH GOP Hands Off: My Body
  • Keep NH GOP Hands Off: My 1st Amendment Rights
  • Keep NH GOP Hands Off: My Tax $
  • Keep NH GOP Hands Off: My Ballot

 

Plymouth Area Democrats
info@plymouthareademocrats.org
www.plymouthareademocrats.org

Fear and Loathing in the White Mountains

by Trysten McClain

It’s mid-morning on a warm spring Tuesday and I’m staring over my favorite hot dirty spiced chai at Cafe Monte Alto while reviewing emails and going over my weekly schedule, pondering to myself, ”How will today go?” I’m referring to House Committee hearings this afternoon. What will today provide for relief or distress? Are the Republicans going to keep playing God, ITL’ing housing relief bills, restricting abortion rights, access, and funds, or any other form of denying another basic human need or right today? Will the hearings include more racist and race-baiting language and scapegoating of whatever choice buzzword the Majority chooses for the appropriate hearing? These are not unfamiliar instances for BIPOC activists, elected officials, and any individual who is engaged in the conversation in our state, nor is it a new issue. Since Black Lives Matter found a substantial amount of support after the murder of George Floyd, everyone regardless of political affiliation has taken up arms to either construct a truthfully inclusive world for society, or fighting to retain the White supremacist, sexist, xenophobic, transphobic, and exploitive class-based control our country was founded on. Quite frankly, it is extremely heartbreaking. I found myself back in New Hampshire about a month after the pandemic began, and was living in my car and on couches of family, pondering if I’ll be safe in Rumney, NH away from the chaos of the New York Tri-State Region and the assumed downfall of humanity. I packed up all my belongings and drove back north all within one evening, and still to this day I remember the horror of driving through Manhattan while hearing countless sirens and seeing next to no pedestrians or traffic. As I found myself starting to gain my feet financially and be stably housed again, I watched the footage of George Floyd’s murder and witness the media explode over the course of three days while wondering about all the past microaggressions and overt instances of racism I experienced. Needless to say, I was PISSED with the world and America in general.

I could not tell you the number of miles I marched this summer if I tried, but I assure you it’s not a reach to say about one million steps were made. Together with so many other people over last summer, many of them who are reading this currently were in attendance at protests or events, organized slow changes locally in creating the conversation regarding human rights and respect for humanity. I could not tell you how many times I heard me or a friend be called racial slurs, told “to get jobs”, “go back home” (while many of us grew up in this area), or received physical threats. Our signs were torn up, and to my knowledge, I had the police called on me six different times over last summer for no reason.  Three of those calls were on the July 4th event on Plymouth Town Common and following march and die-in, even despite the Plymouth police department’s support. One individual screamed at me and called the cops over me playing music. I was playing Marvin Gaye, and clearly, the call was racially driven by that stranger. If you told me I was going to be thrust from a quiet, financially unstable, and reclusive life into being at the front of the conversation on these issues, being approached by reporters and activists, and having a statewide presence that I try to still withdraw from, I’d assume you’re insane.

As of late, I still to this day do not feel welcomed or wanted in my hometown. The hard cold gazes of strangers and acquaintances, the lost interpersonal and family relationships, the asinine commentary, and lack of effort of the community at large to encourage a diverse, inclusive, respected, and youthful community makes me nauseous. But you know what really is the largest issue in the room currently? As discussed in Doctor Martin Luther King Jr.’s famous “Letter from Birmingham Jail”, ‘the Negro’s great stumbling block in his stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen’s Councilor or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate, who is more devoted to ‘order’ than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice […]’. I watched many of those currently reading awkwardly look from afar at our demonstrations, and not a single word was spoken between us besides cordial hellos or the ask of our labor for your campaigns or personal interests. Maybe you shared an Angela Davis quote on Facebook, shared a black box on Instagram, watched the movie Roots, talked to your racist Uncle John or some other hollow form of solidarity instead of working to deconstruct the very foundations and environment you built for my generation and the BIPOC community. One particular jarring instance was a day a friend of mine was canvassing with our local former and current officials on Tenney Mountain Highway. Across the way, a Trumper was abusing him with racist and antagonistic comments. Nobody spoke up for him and the silence was violently loud. As a matter of fact, many of whom were in attendance condemned him for speaking back out of anger after the fact. Do you understand how exploitive that behavior is to our traumas and emotional wellbeing that you could not stand up when the opportunity was provided to your constituents? If you’re upset with these words, you need to take a hard introspective look in the mirror and have a long conversation with yourself and your higher power about your values.

I digress, creating division will not solve the issues we’re continuing to face as our voices are being continually suppressed by folks experiencing white fragility, overt racist citizens and state actors, and oppressive legislature such as HB 544. This article is a call-in, not a call-out. We need you to follow through on the promises, values, and obligations to your constituents made to protect and provide for us. We voted for you because we trust you and we want you to be the leadership we imagine. Piss poor excuses or feigning ignorance is not going to suffice any longer. New Hampshire is an aging state that is gentrifying more by the tic toc second of the clock, and we need to work together. Youth like myself need direction, mentoring, and support for our work. I cannot name a single local representative or senator whoever came to an event, offered direction or support, or had the conversation with local activists from the beginning of this movement. It doesn’t have to be this way. Excluding us from the work is an ugly shade of green on your part. But as quoted by Shirley Chisholm, “If they don’t give you a seat at the table, bring a folding chair.”


Trysten McClain is a current resident of Plymouth, NH who spent most of his life in the greater Grafton region. He is on the Advisory Board for Plymouth Area Democrats, an area activist for LGBTQ+ rights, Black Lives Matter, and inclusion and many other socially progressive Democrat ideals. He is a young man entering into politics and planning a campaign for State Representative in 2022.

The Menace of Absurdity

by Janet Lucas, PAD Blog Editor
Campton, NH

This blog was supposed to be a book review, but a local event with national ties grabbed my attention.  The review will happen later.  Here’s a teaser:  the book begins with a quotation from James Baldwin who wrote “Because even if I should speak, no one would believe me.  And they would not believe me precisely because they know what I said was true”.

I’ve been pondering this quotation ever since our very local event.  Someone posted a sign on the old Armont Inn property one half mile from our home.  The sign appeared to be home-made and it carried a slogan that reminded me of a nonprofit organization familiar to health care providers and  educators called Darkness to Light.  This group empowers laypersons to recognize signs of child sexual abuse and how to prevent this horrendous crime.  The web address is very different from that shown on the sign which read “Dark to Light Save the Children”.  A little research revealed the sign not only co-opted two legitimate and well-known charities but also directs readers to the Q-Anon web site.  My prior knowledge of Q-Anon was that it is a far-right fringe conspiracy group that rants and peddles info-shlock not worth the time and effort to read.  So I ignored it.  That was a huge mistake.

The Q-Anon basic conspiracy theory is that a world-wide group of Satan-worshipping pedophiles control financial markets, politicians and news media and that they engage in cannibalism upon kidnapped children.  They further claim that Donald Trump is the only person who can save the world from this evil cabal.  A claim which, in a very ingenuous fashion, Trump appeared to endorse during a press conference in mid-August 2020.

Ridiculous right?  Who could possibly believe this absurdity?  Millions apparently.  A very similar theory circulated throughout Europe for hundreds of years.  It stated with certainty that Jews kidnapped gentile children and used their blood in satanic rituals.  The Nazi platform in 1920s and 1930s Germany (and in the United States) claimed that Germany lost the First World War not on the battlefield but because Jewish financiers prevented the purchase of armaments by the German government and then blocked its postwar financial recovery.  German intellectuals regarded the Nazis as a laughably inept fringe group and no worse than a shamefully ignorant embarrassment.  We know what happened next.  They were unable to stop the Nazis from using the democratic process to take down the fragile postwar German government.  In a similar fashion, the Republican Party has allowed itself to be taken over and turned into a cult of personality, giving birth to Trumpism.  In the chaos of the COVID pandemic, millions of people have ingested the Q-Anon nonsense and find solace in their online comrades as the only people who truly understand what is happening and are ready for the biblical “storm” that will soon overtake and defeat the international cabal.  It’s a slick combination of an online detective game, religious fundamentalism and phobia.

The old inn’s owner had the Q-Anon sign removed promptly when he was informed of its presence.   The sign was likely posted by a neighbor or someone known to our community.  What do we do about that?  Try to convince them that they’ve been misled?  Try to explain the facts to them? Try to tell them the truth?  Only to hear them deny the truth “precisely because they know it to be true”?  No, that is the dead end that James Baldwin grimly implied.

What must happen now is the defeat of Trumpism.  Reality should be our refuge from discontent, chaos, confusion, paranoia and willful ignorance. People will not turn away from Q-Anon and other wild conspiracy theories until they no longer need them.  We must defeat Trumpism and all of its manifestations from the sign down the road to the festering hatred in the Oval Office.

The Yugely, Bigly Bungler

by Janet Lucas, PAD Blog Editor
Campton, NH

 I’ve been told by my nearest and dearest that I should avoid any gloomy topics in this blog.  Here goes…

     Given how things are going for the President, perhaps he should be planning ahead a little….Fade to orange…..then to gold…..

     It’s the Oval Office.  The President is seated at the Resolute Desk.  He looks at his watch and then he turns to look at the clock surrounded by Goya products on the credenza.  He sighs, turns back and picks up the pen next to the only other object on the desk:  a blank note pad.

     Just then a woman enters through a door opposite the desk.  She’s gray-haired, looks worried and carries a brief case.

     The Prez:  “Great timing!  I’ve just had some thoughts about my Presidential Library.  Have a seat.  Let’s get started.”

     Worried Woman:  “Sir I’m here with an addendum for today’s PDB.  There have been some new developments in Russia and in Korea.” 

     The Prez:  “Great.  OK.  Have a seat.  It will be Hugely Big, my Library.  It will be unprecedented, no more like UNPRESIDENTIAL!!  I’ll put it on…..You’re not writing this down.  What’s your name?

     Worried Woman:  “I’m Undersecretary Susan…

     The Prez interrupting, “Ok Susan be sure to take this down.  I’ll build it on an island…

     (Undersec’y:  thinking  “Fantasy Island?”)

     The Prez:  The public will reach it by private jet.  It’ll be sooo relaxing—they’ll love it.  My people will pick them up in golf carts at the airport.”

     (Undersec’y:  thinking  “His people?  Or the cast of ‘Lost’?  She then imagines a conversation in one of the carts:

          Guest:  “What’s that Black Smoke coming out of the ground?”

          Guide:  “That’s Stephen Miller.  He’s in his Immigrant Interdiction disguise”)

     The Prez:  “They’ll have a preview tour of all the attractions and then be taken to luxury accomodations”

      (Undersec’y:  thinking “No doubt each equipped with a Don’s John”)

     The Prez:  “And then on to the Library.  I see several wings to the building….

     (Undersec’y:  thinking “I see one shelf with your Dick and Jane collection.”

     The Prez:  “We’ll have a wing for the great moments of my Presidentship.  I’m sure there’ll be many.  Of course, great collections, there are always displays of gifts given by foreign leaders and letters from my fans.”

     (Undersec’y thinking:  “Plenty of room for Vlad’s soccer ball, rolls of paper towels, and Cheetos under glass.)

    The Prez:  “Ooh and the ladies.  There has to be a section for them about my presi-dental style and fashions.”

    (Undersec’y thinking:  “Baroque Bordello?  Retrospective on the most frightening Christmas decorations in the history of the White House?”)

The Prez:  “Ok Sally, that’s a start.  I’m a busy man as you know.  Have that back to me in one hour with copies for the cabinet.”

     Undersec’y, relieved to be leaving: “Yes Mr. uh, President”

Hope this gave you a smile!  Now get back to the work of what the great John Lewis described as “getting into good trouble”.

Heat Waves and Pandemics

by Janet Lucas, PAD Blog Editor
Campton, NH

Torrid is not a word normally used to describe northern New Hampshire but as I wrote during the Juneteenth weekend heatwave,  you may refer to this missive as the product of a half-baked brain.  As we edge toward drought after a cold, rainy spring, consider the pendulum swing nearly complete.  We had snow on Mother’s Day and a Frost Warning on June 1st.

The Campton Forward Climate Committee is hard at work on a study to examine the impact of climate change on our community and find ways to mitigate the crisis locally.  They are concerned, self-less citizens spending their time and their resources on behalf of others who may be in denial about global warming.  There have always been folks who push back against innovation especially when it involves science and privilege:  men who fought against women’s suffrage for example.  And the elephant in the room is another:  the cold, hard truth about America the Beautiful:  It was founded upon the genocide of First Nations and built by slave labor.  The white European beneficiaries of these horrible deeds continue to oppress People of Color, resulting in generations of ethnically-undervalued, economically and educationally-deprived citizens suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, substance abuse and their associated public health catastrophes.  YES, GENERATIONS.

Inequality was a subliminal force in my home state of Ohio, the self-described “heart of it all”.  Separated by a historically perilous river crossing from Mitch McConnell’s Kentucky, Ohio is known for race riots in Cincinnati in the mid-1800s, a Copperhead Congressman during the Civil War who ended up fleeing to the Confederacy, the “escape” of Confederate General John Morgan from the Ohio Penitentiary in downtown Columbus, and during my adolescence, the 1966 summer of violence in Hough, a Cleveland neighborhood.  I attended an all-white elementary school.  My parents then moved into  town and my junior and senior high schools were integrated. Ohio’s last census lists a Black population of 12.1% nearly the same as the average for the entire U.S.

So as a retiree immigrant to New Hampshire, in love with its winter (my favorite season), beautiful scenery and proximity to our kids and grandkids, something became obvious early on:  Why is New Hampshire so white (94%) and Vermont and Maine even more so (both 95%)?  During a pandemic and a heat wave many folks are marching in support of Black Lives Matter.  They march in a quest for justice, equality and recognition of historic American truths.  The unequal impacts of the pandemic and climate change are new American truths that mirror the journey of People of Color in colonial America.

European colonists enslaved “hostile” Native Americans especially during King Phillip’s War in the 1660s. (Fisher, Linford 2017)   Around that time, the first Black person in N. H. arrived, enslaved from Africa, in Portsmouth.  The triangle trade enriched many New Englanders (cotton>guns>slaves>repeat or sugar, molasses, rum>tobacco and cotton, etc.).  New Hampshire legally ended slavery in 1783 but may not have completely abolished it until 1853. (Zilversmit, Arthur 1967)  Prince Whipple, a slave who fought with the colonists against the British,  is buried in Portsmouth North Cemetery.  The “African” cemetery for Black people is now paved over under Chestnut Street between State and Court Streets in downtown Portsmouth.  There was a Black community near Kearsarge-Lake Sunapee in the 1840s, long since disappeared. In 1834, abolitionists founded an integrated coeducational school, the Noyes Academy near Canaan, NH.  The Canaan Town Meeting declared the school a nuisance and not long after the school building was pulled off its foundation by a team of oxen provided to the white supremacist anti-abolitionists. e students were given one month to leave town. (New England Historical Society)

Although New England can claim both intellectual and moral leaders of the abolitionist movement, many who fought for the North in the Civil War did so to save the Union.  They were indifferent to the slave-based agrarian society of the South and were openly racist.   Powerful New Englanders complied with fugitive slave laws as an 1851 handbill warned:  “Colored People of Boston, respectively be warned to avoid conversing with the Watchmen and the Police Officers since by the recent order of the Mayor and Aldermen, they are empowered to act as kidnappers and slave catchers.” (New England Society of Antiquities)

After the Civil War, some Blacks fled North to escape failed reconstruction only to join their “free” brethren in segregated communities and ultimately, to be buried in segregated cemeteries.  From 1890-to 1930, the Black Population in the US increased by 60% and between 1915 and 1930 some 7 million Blacks left the South in the Great Migration north. (U.S. Census various sources)  In that same time period, census information shows many New England counties became whiter.  By the time the KKK held its first daylight march in the U.S. in Milo, Maine in 1923, they spent their vitriol on Jews, Catholics and French Canadians because there were so few Blacks left. (Loewen, James 2005) Some Americans of northern European descent self-identified as racially superior and from the 1890s through the 1940s and 1950s espoused a pseudo-science known as eugenics.  Faculty at the University of Vermont advocated coerced sterilization of “inferiors” including the Abenaki People, French Canadians, and poor and disabled people. (Evancie, Angela 2016).  The National Socialist German Workers (NAZI) party in the 1930s was especially interested in this work to the point of inviting some of its American proponents to lecture on the topic in Germany. They learned about American attitudes toward forced sterilization and euthanasia. (Loewen, James 2005).  In reaction to the Great Migration, small towns and communities all over the north, especially in the Midwest and in New England drove out their Black populations with violence, intimidation, restrictive real estate covenants and red-lining into metropolitan ghettos.  In states with few or no large cities, the Black population was completely driven out.

Now New Hampshire faces a choice:  welcome diversity or become a ghost state.  Our population is barely maintained by the immigration of older whites like myself and my wife. This is not the way to keep innovation, creativity and prosperity alive.  The advent of the climate crisis (including ever more frequent pandemics) offers a unique opportunity to attract People of Color back to our state.  It is clear that the warming climate adversely impacts Blacks more than whites. “Women exposed to high temperatures or air pollution are more likely to have premature, underweight or stillborn babies”.  (Flavelle, Christopher in “Climate Change Tied to Pregnancy Risks, Affecting Black Mothers Most”, June 18, 2020).  What better way to ensure that Black Lives Matter than to make sure Black Moms Matter?!  Let’s emphasize the work being done in N.H. to address and mitigate climate change.  We may be a state full of older white people but we can make sure N. H. remains vigorous and innovative in the face of challenge by advertising, inviting, and reaching out to young People of Color.  Consider New Hampshire—we’re cool-er.

 

REFERENCES

Fisher, Linford, associate professor of history at Brown University quoted by Gillian Kelley-Brown in Futurity online magazine in an article entitled “Colonists shipped Native Americans as Slaves” 2/16/2017

Zilversmit, Arthur.  The First Emancipations: The Abolition of  Slavery in the North.   University of Chicago Press, 1967

Evancie, Angela. “What is the Status of the Abenaki Native Americans in Vermont Today?” for Vermont Public Radio, Novermber 4, 2016.

Loewen James W. Sun Down Towns: A Hidden Dimension of American Racism. New York:  The New York Press 2005.

Flavelle, Christopher “Climate Change Tied to Pregnancy Risks, Affecting Black Mothers Most” The New York Times, June 18,2020.

Various from the U. S. Census, the New England Society of Antiquities and the New England Historical Society.

 

Putting Evangelical Support for Trump in the Crosshairs

by Gunnar Baldwin
Plymouth, NH

Since the presidential election in 2016, I have watched in amazement, anger, and disgust as evangelicals across this country have enthusiastically embraced a man whose behavior lacks even a shred of human decency and compassion. It is not that evangelicals have not been on the wrong side of history (and a broad range of ethical issues) all along, but the obvious moral failings Donald Trump would seem to be too hard even for them to swallow. A recent Washington Post article by opinion columnist Elizabeth Bruenig finally helped me pull together a workable explanation—one that is important to understand if we hope to counter evangelicals’ support of Trump in any meaningful way.

Bruenig and others who have written on the this topic explain that it is not that evangelicals are unaware of Trump’s unethical behavior or would condone the same behavior by one of their brethren. Instead, they see him as an instrument used by God to catalyze changes that serve their cause, such as court decisions that further their conservative social agenda and assert Israel’s right to disregard the rights of Palestinians. Trump is seen as necessary strongman, a vehicle for carving out space for fundamentalists to carry out their mission. He has been likened by some right wing evangelicals to King David, another ruler who led a famously adulterous life but who was regarded as a strong protector of the people of Israel.

Consistent with this view, one could point out that many biblical characters, even Judas Iscariot, were seen as instruments of God who were sent to accomplish a divine purpose (such as trigger a resurrection). Yet this viewpoint misses a glaring difference: the Israelites and Christians in the Bible did not seek out, appoint, or condone the acts of the unsavory characters that ultimately furthered “God’s plan” for them. In contrast, evangelical Trump voters actively chose him, and they personally own every hateful and egregious act our President has committed before and during his time in office. They cannot hermetically seal themselves off from personal responsibility for acts of bigotry and cruelty perpetrated or encouraged by him, while enjoying the benefit of conservative court appointees and a newfound freedom to gush homophobic rants. They hired the hitman and they are guilty of his crimes.  

Many recent articles and op-ed pieces in mainstream media suggest Trump is pulling even farther ahead with these groups, improving the odds that he may clinch the election a second time and delivering a coup de grâce to democracy. Why? I would suggest that it is at least partly due to the fact that they are not hearing the right arguments from more progressive members of their fold. In fact, evangelical leaders, such as Jerry Falwell, Jr., have been steadily transforming the view of God’s character held by their constituency from favoring humility and compassion to being a power-God who wants believers to bring about change though brute force, assertiveness, and aggression. In addition, a Pew Research religion poll conducted in 2018 showed that evangelicals were the least likely group—by a wide margin—to believe that America has no responsibility for refugees.

I do not suggest that we can sway large numbers of deeply entrenched red state evangelicals with creative messaging, but right now they are reveling in the mantle of moral superiority virtually unopposed. More than ever, we need bunker buster-caliber challenges that shake the foundations of their cozy fantasy. Trump’s supporters are every bit as culpable for locking children in cages, bankrupting cancer victims, and questioning the patriotism of doule-amputee Mexican-American combat veterans as Trump himself and they need to understand this. 

These messages will not be effective if they are merely perceived as a fresh round of patronizing by ivory tower liberals, a frequently expressed irritant to which they are hypersensitive. Similarly, it is important that they do not perceive that their core religious beliefs themselves are being challenged—just their approach to acting on them. Fortunately, there are a significant number of evangelicals (particularly younger members) who do not buy into the view that their creator wants his flock to consist of authoritarians and fascists, and they are best suited to deliver that message. This segment may be more susceptible to persuasive arguments from progressives, but they must be carefully nudged into vocally challenging the views of their less compassionate counterparts.   

There are a variety of specific topics that should be addressed in Democratic campaign messages that might give more conscientious evangelicals a reason to take pause. Messaging should spotlight the innocent, vulnerable groups who are collateral damage of Trump’s uncompassionate tactics and unfiltered mouth. Examples abound, such as terrified children crowded into filthy detention centers, farmers facing bankruptcy due to trade war political stunts, rapes that are never prosecuted, and homeless people whose employer-provided insurance did not cover enough of the life-saving medical treatment they received. Does their God really want them to be on the hook for these acts of inhumanity as a price for more conservative judges and more stringent abortion laws?

I will end with an anecdote. A family member who once stayed at a Marriot hotel in Salt Lake City (a Mormon-owned chain) and was taken aback to find that he could not order an alcoholic drink to accompany his meal, since the hotel had a strict alcohol-free policy that was consistent with the owner’s religious beliefs. Years later, returning to the same hotel, he was equally surprised to see alcoholic drinks being served in the same dining room. He asked the waitress why the policy had been changed. Without skipping a beat, she informed him that the hotel’s owner had decided that the alcohol ban was unnecessary because serving alcohol was a business decision, not a religious decision. The same type of defense has also been used in court by defendants who carried out contract killings.

During this election, it is imperative to make clear to evangelical voters that their souls are inextricably chained to the heavy cinderblocks of Trump’s abominations and their vote is not an arm’s length “business decision” that can be conveniently abstracted away. However, it will likely not succeed if the message is delivered in a confrontational manner. Diplomatically getting through to—and weaponizing—the moderate ones with constructive messaging may stand the best chance of success. 

PAD districts
House, Senate & Executive Council
Meet the Candidates
Democratic Visibility
Help us get the word out!
Donate
Support our work